86 episodes
- Andy Burnham heads to Brussels this week for a summit with the European Union, after telling the City of London that the hard Brexit Britain was given "is not good enough." Canada isn't waiting. Last month in Montréal, Mark Carney and the EU launched an Alliance for the Future, and Canada is on track to become the EU's first associate member.
Jeremy Purvis, Lord Purvis of Tweed, leads the Liberal Democrats in the House of Lords. He has a name for the next step: “EUR-UK-CA”, a European, UK and Canada agreement. He and Andrew go back to the Brexit years, when they'd argue about Europe in meetings with visiting Canadian MPs and still enjoy each other's company afterwards. They still disagree, agreeably.
What we got into:
What Eureka adds. When Graham Lanktree was on, he told us existing deals already cover 99 percent of Canada–UK trade. Jeremy's answer: a treaty gives the three a standing way to make decisions together and adapt over time, on defence procurement, intelligence sharing, police cooperation and climate rules. Tariffs aren't the big part. Regulation is.
CANZUK or Brussels? Andrew points out that the right gets more excited about Canada, Australia, New Zealand and the UK than about Europe, and asks whether any of this needs Britain back in the EU. Jeremy wants Britain back as a full member one day, but sees Eureka as a stepping stone that works without it.
Does a stronger European defence let America off the hook? Andrew's worry. Jeremy's answer: Sweden and Finland saw no contradiction between building Europe's own capacity and NATO.
After the midterms. Is Europe relieved? Jeremy compares security guarantees to a £5 note: a promissory note, worth only as much as your trust in it. Andrew reads the results as MAGA voters staying home; Jeremy sees a bigger shift.
What would Canadians actually gain? Joseph's dinner-table question. Jeremy: services, jobs, and recognition of professional qualifications, where Britain now needs 27 separate agreements ("bonkers"). Andrew adds shared procurement, the local-content rules that get in its way, and Canada's own barriers between provinces.
What if the EU changes? Andrew raises Marine Le Pen and the AfD. Jeremy, a Scottish Liberal: "Once you've exhausted pessimism, there's only optimism left."
Alberta. One in four Albertans voted to leave Canada last month. Jeremy's reflection from Scotland and Brexit: many who vote to shake things up because they feel they have nothing to lose stand to lose the most.
Also discussed: Liz Truss's Ten Years to Save the West, Andrew's application to become a Liberal Democrat peer (not accepted), and why BC is Scotland, only bigger. - Bill C-39 passed second reading in the House of Commons 296 to 26, with Liberals and Conservatives voting together. Outside Parliament, almost nobody likes it. The Canadian Labour Congress says it gives Ottawa the broadest strike-intervention power in the G7. The Canadian Chamber of Commerce says it ties Ottawa's hands, because a minister could only step in after a strike has started.
Robin Guy made the business case against the bill last week in The Hub. Robin was previously a vice president at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, where he spoke for business during the 2023 West Coast port strike. He joined us to argue it and to look at what last week's federal budget, "Masters of Our Destiny," means for getting things built.
What we got into:
One clause, one word: when. Section 107 is the part of the Labour Code that lets the minister send a dispute to the federal labour board. Under C-39 that power arrives only after a strike starts. Robin's case: rail takes about ten days to wind down, shippers start rerouting as soon as bargaining opens, and the rail contract expires on 31 December, with West Coast ports to follow next spring.
Pro-worker for which workers? Andrew remembers the union battles of 1980s Britain. Robin answers with the workers down the supply chain: manufacturers in Brampton, steelworkers, prairie canola farmers, and slaughterhouses that can't move animals. Joseph thinks animal welfare should lead the business community's campaign next time.
Why not let Parliament vote? On the Labour Congress's alternative, a public-interest panel and a vote before any intervention: back-to-work legislation already takes two or three weeks, and Section 107 is meant to be the tool of last resort.
Conservatives on the picket line. Pierre Poilievre voted for the bill; three weeks later his MPs voted to repeal Section 107 outright. Robin sees a Conservative caucus unlike any in a generation, and thinks the coalition more likely to crack is Mark Carney's.
Masters of our destiny. Andrew thinks it sounds like a Star Wars film. Joseph has a split personality about a $62 billion deficit. Robin went looking for tax simplification and for legislation on the Productivity Mega Deduction, and didn't find either.
Who still makes the case for sound money? Andrew traces the Conservative retreat from Cameron and Osborne to Boris Johnson. Robin: on the economy, the Conservatives have been "out-conservatived."
The prediction. If C-39 passes as written, Robin expects a strike that hits the economy within eight months. "I hope I'm wrong."
Also discussed: business groups that softened their committee testimony because they want the rest of the bill; cargo rerouting through American ports; whether a strike is "elbows up"; and Michelob Ultra, which is not a sponsor.
Robin's piece in The Hub: https://thehub.ca/2026/11/02/bill-c-39-risks-undermining-the-economy-it-is-meant-to-build/ - Andy Burnham has passed 100 days as Prime Minister. Every poll taken in October had Labour first, Reform is down to 20 percent with YouGov, and last week's Budget polled as the fairest since 2021. Then his Chancellor said on the radio, "We had a referendum. We're out," three days after Burnham said he'd like Britain back in the EU in his lifetime.
So we brought back Simon Hart: Rishi Sunak's Chief Whip from start to finish, former Welsh Secretary, now Lord Hart of Tenby, and author of Ungovernable, his diaries of holding the Tory parliamentary party together as it fell apart.
What we got into:
"If this is as good as it gets." Simon's read on the Burnham bounce: a seven- or eight-point lead at what may be the high-water mark, with defence, welfare and departmental cuts all pushed into next year.
A fiver from your granny. Why the smallest Budget in years landed well: it did no harm and was sold as a breather, not a cure. Andrew's mam texted to say the £100 had paid for Christmas dinner.
Farage has lost form. Simon's cricket analogy, which he concedes won't travel to Canada. Reform fired its one weapon years early, answers scrutiny the Trumpian way, and the defectors who left for a seat at the top table are now looking at losing their own. "I'm counting the moments until they start eating themselves alive in public."
The case for an early election, and against. None of Burnham's opponents want one now, which is exactly why he might. Then 2017: 20 points ahead going in, two coming out, Simon's majority down to a couple of thousand. Andrew's went up, which he would like noted.
Two Tories on the referendum. Andrew voted Leave on principle. Simon was a "sceptical Remainer" who expected ten years of political nightmare whichever side won. Both think Burnham should leave that fire unlit.
The ballot question. What does each side want voters answering on election day? Andrew can answer for Kemi Badenoch and not for Burnham: "I don't really know what he believes." Simon: an offer that works in Godalming and in Brigg and Goole.
Also discussed: No 10's communications, "night and day" from the Starmer era, except, Simon says, for having nothing to communicate; the B.C. snap election as a warning; the Queen Mary lecture tour and why Andrew wasn't offered steerage; and whether there's a second volume of the diaries.
Ungovernable is published by Pan Macmillan. Find Simon's writing at the Spectator. - Five weeks ago, Sean Speer was on the show to help us pick through what was left of the B.C. Conservatives after Kerry-Lynne Findlay quit. Two days later, David Eby called an election two years early. On Saturday the Conservatives won 63 of 93 seats, their first win in their own right since 1928, under an interim leader who has never sat in cabinet.
So we brought in Todd Stone, who has. Todd was B.C.'s transportation minister under Christy Clark and Kevin Falcon's House Leader, with Lorne Doerkson as his caucus chair. He now runs the Association for Mineral Exploration, which has a lot riding on what this government does next.
What we got into:
A Cinderella story with a pop-up shop. Todd compares the Conservative campaign to a Christmas kiosk at the mall: thirty days to find a leader, a platform, the money, and the inventory, then sell.
"You might as well call it brand X." Social Credit, B.C. Liberal, B.C. Conservative. Todd on the coalition that keeps changing its name, and what always holds it together.
Who is Lorne Doerkson? Rodeo MC, dunk-tank volunteer, and the MLA who grabbed a hose and went behind the fire lines. Todd shares what Doerkson told him the night before the vote.
A cabinet with no cabinet experience. By Todd's count, nobody in the incoming government has been a minister. He names his pick for finance, and the MLA he thinks could lead the party one day.
The quarter-million who stayed home. The NDP vote collapsed, but it didn't go anywhere. Todd's warning to his own side about reading too much into the mandate.
DRIPA, carefully. Todd voted for it in 2019. What he was told at the time, and how he'd handle a repeal without losing the first year to it.
Also discussed: the B.C. Conservatives inviting Andrew to their caucus retreat ("desperation, capital D"), why voters didn't need a premier to fight Trump when they'd already hired Mark Carney, John Horgan as "Premier Dad," Andy Burnham's breathing-space budget, and Andrew noticing we'd assembled a balanced panel of three conservatives.
Todd's call: the books are worse than anyone has been told. We'll have him back after the first budget to check. His predictions, he says, are "worth what you paid for them."
Find Todd at the Association for Mineral Exploration (ame.ca) and on X at @toddstonebc. - Eight months ago Dave Cournoyer told us the pro-Canada side in Alberta had no leader, no campaign, and no ground game. It became our most-listened-to episode ever. On Monday that side won three to one, so Dave is back — solo host this week, both of us nursing colds — to explain how, and why the Premier's week got harder after the result.
Dave has covered Alberta politics for twenty years at Daveberta, the Substack I turn to for Alberta.
What we got into:
Ten ballots, ten boxes, no tabulators. Why the count ran into Thursday and why one First Nation ran out of ballots.
The nine questions few polled. The government expected all of them to pass at 60 or 70 percent. Immigration scraped through; the constitutional questions all lost. Dave on the $4 million ad campaign that was "long-winded, vague, and confusing" at the same time.
"I voted to abolish the Senate. I lost. I'll take the L." Why nobody outside the political-nerd caucus had the Senate in their top ten.
Half a million leave voters. A message to Ottawa, or the real base? How the separatist pitch drifted from draft constitutions to "let Albertans decide."
Who knocked the doors. The NDP ran a get-out-the-vote operation; the governing party, as far as Dave could tell, didn't to nearly the same extent
The Premier's November problem. Thousands of members at the convention, a push to make separatism party policy that lost by one board vote last year, and a leader who just told her most active organizers to park their beliefs or leave.
Also discussed: Calgary-Shaw as the warning sign, why Thomas Lukaszuk deserves more credit than he's getting, Pollara's finding that separatists think Smith is a federalist and federalists think she's a separatist, the Quebec playbook (start a party, or take over the one you're in), and following ten counts from a Halifax hotel room at 1 a.m.
Dave's call: the next big moment in Alberta politics is the UCP convention in late November. We'll have him back once the Premier is through it.
Find Dave at daveberta.substack.com and on the Daveberta Podcast.
More Government podcasts
Trending Government podcasts
About Craft Politics
Craft Politics is a cross-border political podcast, which sounds grander than it is. Mostly it's two friends — Joseph Lavoie, a Canadian public affairs strategist who used to work in a Prime Minister's Office, and Andrew Percy, a former UK Conservative MP — asking the experts who'd know the answer to one sharp political question. Canadian listeners get the UK context they're missing. British listeners get a Canadian lens on their own politics. Everyone comes away slightly better informed.
Podcast websiteListen to Craft Politics, The Coming Storm and many other podcasts from around the world with the radio.net app

Get the free radio.net app
- Stations and podcasts to bookmark
- Stream via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth
- Supports Carplay & Android Auto
- Many other app features







































